Padel Browser
💬 Discussion 💬

I Tracked My Padel Stats and Used AI to Analyse Them — Full Match Recording and Chat

025 commentsu/beccylina5d ago
I recorded a match I played last week and whilst I was watching it back I counted all the errors and winners and ended up sharing the data with AI, alongside each player's Playtomic rating, to see what it had to say. I'm new to padel and learning so this ended up being very valuable activity for me, and was also surprising. I uploaded the match for the other players to watch, and was pretty excited about it so I share the analysis in a 8 minute chat at the beginning. Sharing here for those that are interested in using AI to track and improve their game too, and curious to hear others thoughts. Please be kind and provide constructive feedback :)
https://youtu.be/PVLf9sIDork?si=EDOH5N6Q_w7rJzfn

Comments (25)

Like mentioned here before: at this level, relying on winners and unforced errors can be very misleading. You can make poor decisions throughout a match and still win, not because you played well, but because your opponents performed worse. Let me give you a real example from a match I reviewed. The player, an intermediate right-side player, played a lob on his opponent of a ball that went into the middle of the court, just on the middle line, the opponent mishit the ball badly and put it into the net. So I sent him the clip of that particular point and didn't said anything, and he told me "Whats the problem here? I did a lob and he smashed the net, his error” But that’s not what actually happened The lob was placed down the middle and he kept looking at what happened while standing in the middle of the court, leaving his side completely open, he did not recover his defensive position toward his corner afterward. That’s a fundamental mistake. A more aware opponent would have easily redirected the ball into the open space and finished the point easily. So no,the lob wasn’t “great.” but his position was the worst thing in that scenario and was super obvious to me, but not to him. - When I pointed his position he send me a facepalm emoji and replied "of course... what am I doing?" It was a poor decision that happened to work because the opponent made an even bigger mistake. This is exactly the trap many players fall into: judging their performance based on the outcome rather than the quality of their decisions. Winning a point doesn’t always mean you played it well. And losing a point doesn’t always mean you played it badly, making a good mistake and losing a point is better than making a bad one and winning one if what you're focusing on is your improvement. If you really want to improve, you need to shift your mindset: Focus on decision-making, not just results Evaluate positioning, shot selection, and intent Ask: “Would this work against a better opponent?” I also recommend watching this video it reinforces this concept really well and will help you start seeing the game more critically: [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToJ6rtq4-dw](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToJ6rtq4-dw)
5
u/beccylinaOP3d ago
(Wow, firstly I just want to say how grateful I feel for the feedback from everyone here ☺️) Thank you for such a detailed response and sharing the example! What you said about making "good mistakes" resonated. I knew to myself in that match that my smashes would have been easily returned by higher rated players but was too keen to win in the moment. Too bad Claude can't help me analyse my shot selection and decision making, I could really benefit from that and I'll try to ask a coach to review it together a bit tomorrow. Also had no idea that such AI cameras existed in recreational clubs until you shared that interesting video discussion. Thanks again!
1
Interesting experiment. At this point in your development I wouldn't focus too much on winners and errors though. What is important is starting to make good decisions and learn proper technique. Example: A "bad" shot may very well end up being a winner at this level, just as a good decision may result in an error because of technical issues. Of course, you don't really learn technique when playing matches, that is something you do in training sessions with a coach. When playing matches focus on good decision making. For instance in this match all four players are prone to playing for too much compared to their technical abilities. In padel, building points until you get a chance to finish it is pretty crucial. Likewise, all four players could benefit from thinking of most padel shots as "guiding" or "pushing" the ball, rather than "hitting" it. Good luck with your development!
4
u/beccylinaOP5d ago
Thank you so much for your thoughtful feedback! Interesting and I really appreciate it. I completely agree that we were hitting the ball too much, having just come back from practicing in Spain. I actually found it difficult not to respond by hitting back in this match, I honestly would have much preferred not to call on my tennis response in that situation. Thanks again!
1
u/Aizpunr3d ago
Idk, i feel this is such an incomplete analysis (only winners, errors and ratings) that is basically not very helpful imo.
2
u/beccylinaOP3d ago
I asked Claude on a whim not expecting much. I agree with the comment that the focus at our level should be on technique rather than analysis
1
u/Aizpunr3d ago
Analysis is very good. Technique is only 1/4 of the game (mental, physical and tactics being the other big parts) The thing is focusing on why you make errors / winners is how you progress (was it a technique problem? Did you compromise your tactics with shot selection or court position? Are you concentrated? Are you making a second error immediately after making an error because your head is still there? Are you coasting or giving up?)
1
When I read AI analysis on padel, I was expecting a bit more in depth technical analysis. Not so much, these are my shots, this is what happened. Is overly simplistic but I guess is valid (?) Just feels clickbait.
1
In the video description on YouTube you say: "If you're a recreational padel player curious about how to use AI to analyse your own game — no cameras, no sensors, just match data and Claude — I hope this gives you some ideas." But you can't do this analysis without a camera recording, right?
1
u/beccylinaOP5d ago
Ah sorry, I meant not using those AI cameras that have sensors built in to track, as I used a normal camera. Will correct
2
How did you use claude what kindoff prompt and did you have a paid version? 
1
Small point of feedback for your padel play: Try to turn you body more for overheads, your left shoulder should be pointing towards where you want to hit the ball, see 21:00 for example Also if you ever see your teammate, shes losing so many points with error at the net with overheads and volleys because shes preparing her racket behind her head or too far from the ball for her skill level
1
u/beccylinaOP5d ago
Thank you for watching and sharing the feedback. I will think about this the next time I'm on court. I didn't notice that about my teammate since I'm new and still trying to execute padel overheads. All I could see was that her racket preparation looks more "padel like" than mine (which looks "tennis like") - luckily she trains every week with a group, so I'm sure she's getting this feedback from the coach rather than coming from me!
2
Please stop posting these, really no value at all.
-4
That's a harsh comment. Wouldn't say a video about padel analysis have no value at all in a padel subreddit.
3
You are free to ignore them.
2
u/beccylinaOP5d ago
Noted, thank you for the feedback
2
I like your post, I also enjoyed your entire YouTube! Great to see people playing and learning this game.
2